Florida: State Employee Raises v. Total Compensation Reduction
An article in The Florida Current reports that the Florida legislature has come to an agreement to give career service state employees a raise — the first in almost seven years. Career service workers earning more than $40K a year would see a $1K increase, and those earning less than that would get a $1.4K increase.
It’s not much, for sure, but it is a step in the right direction.
A definite step in the wrong direction was the State Supreme Court blessing the money grab labeled as “pension reform” earlier this year. In 2011, career service employees, then five years from any general raise in salary, were mandated to contribute 3% of their salary to the pension plan. Gov. Rick Scott cited common practice in private industry and other states of requiring employee salary contributions to retirement plans in pushing for this change, but nowhere was it said that it was common practice anywhere to reduce employee total compensation unilaterally. Instead of increasing funding to the pension plan, the state simply reduced its total contribution to the pension plan, effectively reducing employee total compensation.
The two countervailing results can be tallied up together to yield an effective compensation change value now.
Salary | Reduction in total compensation | Raise | Effective compensation change |
10000 | -300 | 1400 | 1100 |
15000 | -450 | 1400 | 950 |
20000 | -600 | 1400 | 800 |
25000 | -750 | 1400 | 650 |
30000 | -900 | 1400 | 500 |
35000 | -1050 | 1400 | 350 |
40000 | -1200 | 1000 | -200 |
45000 | -1350 | 1000 | -350 |
50000 | -1500 | 1000 | -500 |
55000 | -1650 | 1000 | -650 |
60000 | -1800 | 1000 | -800 |
65000 | -1950 | 1000 | -950 |
70000 | -2100 | 1000 | -1100 |
If you are a career service state employee making less than $40K per year, the legislature’s proposed raise will provide more positive change in compensation than the “pension contribution” reduced it. If, though, you are making more than $40K per year, the amount of the the salary raise is less than the total compensation amount removed by the “pension contribution”; you are still effectively in the hole or underwater or whatever term might apply to this form of being shafted by your employer.
Of course, the expected compensation change is for one year only. The legislature’s raise is a one-time event that might or might not be repeated next year. But the total compensation reduction of the “pension reform” is an ongoing year-by-year reduction the career service employees will be experiencing on and on into the future.
Update: Looking at this again, I have to correct myself here. The legislature is giving a raise, so that part carries forward. State employees lost total compensation without anything offsetting that from 2011 until whenever this raise goes into effect. The offset values in the table then apply to the situation going forward from the point the raises take effect.